Mexican-Americans: The Legacy of Conquest vs. Cuban Enclave

I. Treaty of Guadeloupe Hildago (1848): Mexico surrenders over 1/3 territory to U.S.

A.Mexico must accept after U.S. armies invade during Mexican-American War

B.75,000 Mexican nationals guaranteed their land grants; bilingual official documents

C.Language not respected; within 10 years, much property lost through Anglo duplicity

1. Mexican tradition based on vague landmarks is manipulated in Anglo courts

2. Anglo hunger for Mexican’s land fuels conflict

II.Mexican resistance to abuse, land seizures in Southwest labeled as criminal

A.Bandido image used to denigrate rebellions

B.Example of Cortina Wars and “Red Robber Barron of the Rio Grande”

1.Wealthy Juan Cortina had large land grant, was incensed by Anglo treatment

2.Kills sheriff seen pistol-whipping one of his mother’s workers

3.Frees Mexican prisoners from Brownsville jail, is labeled a “bandit” by Anglos

C. Many Mexicans are lynched

III.Mexicans exploited as cheap, temporary workforce to be expelled when not needed

A.Depression fuels repatriations in 1930s: 1 million returned 1926-1939

B.Bracero program 1942-1964: cheap guest agricultural workers popular with growers

1.Objective was to exploit labor then send back to Mexico

2.Created infrastructure of illegal migration

C.Operation Wetback in 1954: response to recession is to send back Mexicans

D.Message of “Born in East LA:” US citizens without papers sent to Mexico

E.IRCA (Simpson-Rodino bill) in 1986: Hispanics at disadvantage--employer checks ID

IV.Discrimination

A. Example of Zoot Suit Riots in 1943: Sailors attack “pachucos” and riot in barrio

B. L.A. council makes wearing a zoot suit misdemeanor:baggy pants,long coats of youth

C. Sleepy Lagoon Trial: Mexicans labeled “criminal;” teens jailed on evidence thrown out

V. Mexicans deprived of cultural and physical capital

A.Physical capital: land, factories, other property that embodies or produces wealth

B.Cultural capital: education, experience, skills, social contacts, reputation, etc.

VI.Contrast with Ethnic Enclave of Cubans, built from Cultural and Physical Capital

A.Successes:>25,000 businesses (1990), 40% of wealthiest Hispanics, mayors/legislators

B.Key: Golden exiles use cultural, physical capital to build economic enclave

1.Provide ingredients for “society in embryo” absorbing future migrant waves

2.Cubans from all classes come voluntarily to create better way of life

3.Exile status, language, common experience create strong bonds

C.3 Components of Enclave Economy (Alejandro Portes)

1. Ethnic solidarity transcending economic, contractual ties

A.Rotating credit associations: informal credit on reputation vs. collateral 

B.Informal benefits vs. lower wages: creates niche for new competitors

1.On the job training2.Rapid promotions

3.Help in establishing own business later on

2. Some business--e.g.,banking--competes with Anglos; not just periphery of econ

3.Geographic concentration: close to ethnic clients, labor, other businesses

a.upshot: can succeed in enclave’s sector without having to speak English

back to class notes index