American Indians in Phase II

Post-Colonial Policies of Cultural Subversion and Control

I.California: the last frontier for military suppression of Indians

A. Murder of Indians legalized and publically subsidized in California

1. 1851/52 Cal authorizes > $1 million for vigilantes “supressing Indian hostilities”

B. Indians primarily viewed as obstacles to be removed rather than as free labor power

1.Exception: slavery in South Carolina for limited duration

2.California: Act for the Government and Protection of Indians (1850-1863)

a.Indian Children auctioned off at $50-$200 after parents murdered

b.Indentured servitude for up to 10,000 Indians is close to slavery 

II.The Second Phase of American Policy: BIA subversion of Indian culture

A.Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA) founded 1824: originally within War Department

1. No other ethnic group subject to such control by single bureaurcacy

2.Control exercised much like total institutions (e.g., prisons, mental institutions)

a.Agent’s powers: over schools,; is judge, jury, police;could expel,cut hair

b.Indians have no say; dependent on burearcracy in Washington, DC 

c.Agent’s social life segregated from Indians, like British in India

d.Indian’s veiwed as helpless because of dependency created by BIA

B.Full citizenship not granted until 1924

1.Supreme Court ruled in 1880s that 14th Amendment does not apply to Indians

C.BIA 4 pronged policy of cultural subversion and control (1st 3 from Edward Spicer)

1. Religious replacement: Code of religious offenses; missionaries assigned

2.Compulsory education: children sent away from parents to boarding schools

a.Objective of “weaning off blacket”--meaning to eliminate culture 

3.Individual landholding: Dawes Act of 1887

a.Contrary to collective possession in Indian culture (spiritually ordained)

b.Reformers want to destroy tribal identity,create self-sufficient individual

c.Allotment of 40-160 acres to each family, sell rest to whites

d.Main results: Indians lose 2/3 of land, become more dependent on BIA

4.Centralization and secularization of political authority: Indian Reform Act 1934

a.repudiation of ½ century of Dawes Act

b.recognizes tribal identity

c.allows for election of reservation board

d.Contrary to Indian culture (Edward Spicer, Cycles of Conquest )

1. Southwest Indians had collective leadership--adult males over 40

2.Chief collectively recognized for wisdom

3.Chief rituralistic-moralistic leader with no power to punish

4.Administrative-executive leaders turn world upside down

a.Like putting war leaders in charge during peacetime

III.Termination Policy of 1953

A. Doesn’t recognize contradictions created by forced removal; basis of white privilege

back to class notes index