Religious Ritual
REL 5023

                   Texts
                    Course Description
                    Calendar
                    Assignments
                    September 11*
 
 
 
Leopards break into the temple and drink the sacrificial chalices dry. This happens again and again,  repeatedly. Finally it can be counted on beforehand and becomes part of the ceremony.

                      --Franz Kafka, Parables
 


 
TEXTS

Required

  • Lehmann and Myers, eds. Magic, Witchcraft, and Religion 
  • Bell, Ritual: Perspectives and Dimensions
  • Kertzer, David.  Ritual, Politics, and Power
  • articles as assigned
  • Notes
    Lehmann and Myers is a good, anthropologically oriented anthology (one of several available) of articles that we are using to illustrate topics covered in class.  Bell is an excellent introduction to ritual studies, chock full of information though not a great read.  Kertzer is a readable classic that opens up the question of ritual in civic and secular contexts.

    DESCRIPTION

                                   This course is offered in conjunction with REL 3022,
                                    Ritual in Religion and Culture.  Graduate students attend
                                    lectures and other class sessions concurrently with students
                                    in REL 3002, with an extra, contiguous grad seminar hour.

                                    Grads will read the Lehmann and Myers anthology on the
                                    same schedule with undergrads, but will be assigned
                                    extensive additional reading (students should read these
                                    on a prudent schedule of their own devising).  This
                                    semester, grads will focus on ritual, politics, and the very
                                    fuzzy line between religious and non-religious ritual.
     
     
     
     
    COURSE LECTURE CALENDAR

     AUG28  Introduction to course; syllabus, course policies 

     SEP   2   LABOR DAY -- NO CLASS

              4   What is ritual? 
                        READ: Harris; Bell, ch. 1

              9   Ritual functions
                        READ: Bell, ch. 2

            11  *CLASS CANCELLED 

    to allow student participation in and observation of campus 9-11 activities (to be included in paper!)    READ:  Bell, ch. 4 
            16  Symbol in ritual 
                        READ:  Firth, 64; Hand, 197 

            18  Myth and ritual 
                        READ:  Bell, ch. 3; Leech, 39; Douglas, 68 
                Presentation:  Iliana Hakes-Martinez

            23  Shamanistic ritual: Spirit and Vision 
                        READ: Turner; Howells; Brown

            25  Priestly ritual: liturgy and sacrament 
                        READ: Furer-Haimendorf
                Presentation: David Plummer  must be rescheduled

            30  Functions of religious ritual 
                        READ: Geertz; Lee

     OCT 2  Ritual Characteristics 
                        READ: Bell, ch. 5
                    Presentation:  Janine Feiger

             7  Ritual and psychology 
                        READ: deRopp; Bergman; Bass; Pattison 

             9  Magic and Ritual 
                        READ: Levi-Strauss; Brown; del Guercio; Singer 
                  Presentation:  Arica Whatmore

            14 Trance States:  Ruben Garrote
                        READ: Brain; Orion

            16  Rites of passage 
                        READ: Turner; Gordon
                Presentation:  Walter Milner  must be rescheduled

            21  Rites of passage: A case 

            23  Ancestors and Ritual 
                        READ:  Mitchell; Truzzi
                Presentation:  Katy Roper

            28  Ritual and culture 
                        READ:  Bell, ch. 6-7; Puttick

            30  Ritual, politics, and power 
                        READ: Lewis; Slotkin
                Presentation: Regina Undorfer

    NOV  4  Ritual and the Third Reich 

             6  American civil religion 
              DUE:  Assignment 2
               Presentation: Jeff Sitkiewitz

           11  VETERANS' DAY--no school

           13  Sports as ritual
                        READ: Gmelch
                Presentation: Gretchen Scharnagl

           18  The body: beauty, violence, and sacrifice 
                        READ: Dubitsch; Miner

           20  Ritual healing :  Michael Martinez, Kelly Muldoon
                        READ:  Kiev; Wedenoja
                Presentation:  Katherine Hermann

           25 Ritualizing death 
                        READ: Barber; Metcalf

           27  Ritual salvation: Cults, Sects, and Revitalization 
                        DUE:  Assignment 3
                        READ: Wallace; Worsley; Daugherty; Newsweek
                Presentation:  Nawa Chaulagain

    DEC 2  Ritual as cultural criticism 
                        READ: Sagan, 384 

            4  Return to the question: What is ritual? 
                       Presentation:  Julie Lopez
    ____________________________________________________________

     "READ"  = to be read by date shown on syllabus 
     "DUE"    = to be handed in on the day indicated


      

    ASSIGNMENTS

    Assignment 1

    Choose a topic related to religious ritual for development and presentation to the class in seminar format. Presentations should take at least 25 minutes or so and be followed by questions and discussion. 

    In general, you should choose a topic related to your thesis, work in another course, interest in another discipline (e.g., psychology or anthropology), area study (Judaism, Asian religion, etc.), previous research, or area of expertise.  That is, it is desirable that the assignment be used as an opportunity to integrate knowledge, using ritual as the thematic focus within a larger context.  This is called efficient and productive scholarly activity.
     

    Assignment 2

    Read Kertzer, Grimes, and any other material I may come up with to supplement our study of the relationship of politics, religion, and ritual.  Carefully watch and read up on anniversary observances of the events of September 11.  Write a critical essay examining religion, ritual, and public ceremonial, using 9-11 as a model or paradigm.  Evaluate such questions as

    • the impact and effectiveness of public rituals
    • ritual techniques that make them effective
    • the human need or tendency (or not) to ritualize
    • the use of religious language and imagery in public rituals
    • ritual spontaneity in public life
    • manipulation of public reaction/opinion/emotion using ritual
    • the extent to which ritual makes politics/nationalism a kind of "religion"
    • why an event like 9/11 is "ritualizable"
    • other events that have occasioned a similar reaction
    • the exclusiveness--or not--of various supposedly "religious" ritual behaviors
    • establishing a definition of religious ritual
    • etc., etc.


    The resulting paper should exhibit proper use of an accepted scholarly annotation style, good writing, logical organization and development, thoroughness, and (of course) solid critical thinking.

    Assignment 3

    Attend at least three (3) ritual events (to be determined in class).  For each event, write a report describing the event, highlighting those elements which you found interesting in terms of the material of the course, relating what you have seen to other experiences you have had, and bringing to the event a critical analytical approach.  Apply good principles of field research (insofar as that is possible) to your observation, with careful attention to detail, affect, participants' understanding of the event (not always the last word!), setting, intended purpose, deviations from "standard" performances of the event, roles of performers, and so on.

    Look for the details--you want a "thick description."  Consider the following aspects of the ritual:
    (1)  the intended "users" of the ritual
     (2)  the individual, step-by-step elements of the ritual
     (3)  the structure of the rituals
     (4)  the symbols used in the rituals
     (5)  how the symbols are used
     (6)  the root metaphor(s) that underly the symbols
     (7)  the myth(s) the symbols reflect or draw upon
     (8)  the function the rituals serve for the individual and the group/community/society that uses them
     (9)  the appropriateness of the rituals
     (10) the effectiveness of the rituals
     (11) the relationships described/formed/expressed
     (12) the identities described/formed/expressed

    Take note of things like (this isn't a "to do" list!)
                     Leaders 
                          Is there one person who controls most of the meeting?
                          Were the leaders set apart by special clothing?
                          Are they set apart by special training or ordination?
                          What part do others play in the ceremony?
                          Is there much interaction between the leader(s) and the audience?
                     Message/sermon/homily
                          How long was it?
                          Was it the central part of the service?
                          What place did scripture have in it?
                          Was it "rational" or did it play to the emotional side of the audience?
                     Architecture
                          Is the building plain or ornate?
                          Does the structure relate anything particular about this group?
                          Are there many religious symbols (crosses, candles, banners, images)?
                          How is the platform/altar area arranged? What does this tell you what this 
                          group considers most important?
                     Music
                          Was there much, or any, singing?
                          How would you characterize the music--somber, lively, traditional, etc?
                          What part, if any, did the songs play in the overall experience?
                          Were instruments used?  Which ones?  What affect did they have?
                     Ritual Behavior
                          How intricate was it? 
                          What did the congregation do?  Did they stand, sit, bow, kneel?
                          Was the service difficult to follow for the uninitiated?
                          Were there ritual actions that seemed distinctive to this group?
                          How were the beliefs and history of the group reflected in the service?
                     Congregation
                           How was the congregation dressed?
                           How many attended?
                           What was the attitude toward start time of the service?
                           How did they behave overall?
                           What proportions of men/women/children were there?
                           Did children stay throughout the service, or go elsewhere?  When and why?
                           What was the age profile of the congregation?
                           Were women, men, and children treated alike?
     
     

    Turn in all 3 reports together.

    OR

    An alternative research project you discuss with me first.